Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars

Back in college, my roommate Jenn and I put away some Nutty Buddy bars (chocolate peanut butter cookie bars). This highly processed “treat” is not something you might wonder if it would pass the real food test…clearly, anything by Little Debbie does not! So I have not had one in a while. I think the ingredients say it all…

photo of Nutty Buddy Bars by Little Debbie

But boy, do I remember exactly how they taste. And the other day Jenn said to me, ”When are you going to come up with a Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars recipe so we can make them at home?” It honestly had not occurred to create a homemade version, but I was up for the challenge.

And, while the result is not exactly like the original (I am not about to whip up some wafers from scratch), these homemade nutty bars are pretty reminiscent of what used to be my favorite packaged dessert! Let me know if you agree in the comments. :)

Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars on 100 Days of Real Food
Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars on 100 Days of Real Food

Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars

These copycat Nutty Buddy Bars are free of processed ingredients and pretty reminiscent of what used to be my favorite packaged dessert. Hope you enjoy!
4.7 from 7 votes
Prep Time: 15 mins
Chill Time: 30 mins
Total Time: 45 mins
Print Recipe
Servings: 12 bars

Ingredients
  

  • 24 Triscuit (or similar) crackers
  • 1/2 cup peanut butter we buy natural peanut butter made with 1 ingredient, peanuts!
  • 1 1/4 cups chocolate chips
  • 1/4 cup heavy cream

Instructions
 

  • Spread peanut butter on top of each cracker then double them up (one on top of another) to make 12 double-decker stacks.
  • In a small pot over very low heat, melt the chocolate chips and heavy cream together. Continuously stir until smooth, 2 to 3 minutes. You can also use a double boiler, but if you keep a close eye and stir frequently, I don’t think it’s necessary.
  • Line a baking sheet or cutting board with parchment or wax paper. One by one dip each cracker stack in the melted chocolate and spoon over top. Take out of the chocolate, scrape the excess off the bottom (with the spoon), and place on the prepared sheet. Repeat until done.
  • Place in the entire thing in the freezer until chocolate sets, 1 to 2 hours, and serve. Keep cold. 

Notes

We recommend organic ingredients when feasible.
Nutrition Facts
Nutrition Facts
Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars
Amount Per Serving
Calories 167 Calories from Fat 90
% Daily Value*
Fat 10g15%
Saturated Fat 4g25%
Cholesterol 10mg3%
Sodium 73mg3%
Potassium 76mg2%
Carbohydrates 17g6%
Fiber 1g4%
Sugar 13g14%
Protein 4g8%
Vitamin A 115IU2%
Vitamin C 0.1mg0%
Calcium 29mg3%
Iron 0.4mg2%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Posts may contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product through an affiliate link, your cost will be the same but 100 Days of Real Food will automatically receive a small commission. Your support is greatly appreciated and helps us spread our message!

25 thoughts on “Copycat Nutty Buddy Bars”

  1. 4 stars
    Thinking about trying this with a butter waffle cookie. Might taste closer to the real deal over a triscuit. Overall good though.

  2. I know that Triscuit crackers only have 3 ingredients and those ingredients are all real food, but what about the BHT preservative that they pump into it “to preserve freshness” according to their box?

    Doesn’t adding a possible carcinogen preservative kick it out of your real food guidelines?

    1. Never mind, I see that you addressed this earlier in the thread. I’m sad to say I will not be buying triscuits, but hope to try this recipe with a similar cracker that doesn’t contain BHT.

  3. I wasn’t sure if I would like these. I thought they might might be sweet enough, and thought about adding honey to the peanut butter. I’m so glad I made them exactly as posted. No need for extra sweetner. They were just right. I used organic dark chocolate chips.

  4. 5 stars
    My grandson (5 1/2) and I made these this weekend! Our chocolate was a little stiff, even after a bit more cream and some coconut oil, but we loved them! They were not as pretty as Lisa’s (most of the chocolate was on top) but the taste/texture was very appealing! He said we should make them again!

  5. y8830@hotmail.com

    5 stars
    SO easy and SO much like a Nutty Buddy! Definitely a close imitation and I wouldn’t change anything about this recipe. Not to mention feeling no guilt after eating them! Thank you so much for this reward after making such a lifestyle change.

  6. I wonder if there might be some kind o waffle f ice cream cone made of healthy ingredients that could be used instead of Triscuits…

  7. 5 stars
    These are SO GOOD! I wasn’t sure about using triscuits but i was pleasantly surprised. The texture is what makes them special!
    Great recipe, thanks for sharing!

  8. Organic Triscuits are available, and as far as I can tell, they don’t contain BHT in the packaging.

    1. April Heimerle

      Lol! It’s just a small square shaped shredded wheat “cracker” (as we call them here). Triscuit is the brand name. (I think they’re made by Nabisco?) They have several flavors, depending on the seasoning powder, with plain being the only type I’ve seen mentioned on this site. However, you’re not missing much as the commentors before suggested…they have preservatives in their packaging.

  9. It is a great idea to replicate those delicious heavenly treats. :-)
    I also would like to think if an alternative to triscuits. Something more delicate. Maybe a rice based water would work. Vanilla in the wafer seems like a flavor that would help resemble the original.
    But the texture of them is the key thing that appeals to me, so I will try to think of a less dense and more simple water than the Triscuits.
    Thanks for the inspiration!

  10. Hayley Gardner

    Hi Lisa! I am such a lover of your blog and cookbooks! Your blog literally changed my life! I was SO SO excited to see this post as I use to love those treats. I do have a question regarding this recipe. Not sure if you are aware but the packaging of Triscuits has BHT in it, a preservative. When I first began this journey of eliminating processed foods and preservatives from my diet BHT was one of the things I learned about. It is a terrible preservative that has been linked to cancer. So my question is are you using a different type of cracker or the actual Triscuit brand and if so do you know something about BHT that I don’t as I would love to know because many of the kellogg brands have BHT in their packaging and due to popular demand they are in the process of eliminating it from their packaging. Thanks in advance for sharing your knowledge and I appreciate all you do!

    1. Hi, Hayley, I think a slightly improved option may be the Back to Nature brand crackers that are similar to Triscuits. I am also wondering if a Wasa cracker ( made from rye) may be substituted for some people who cannot eat wheat. I might add a little extra salt in there to compensate for the unsalted nature of Wasa crackers.

    2. I’m holding a box of Trisciots right now that I purchased about a week ago. There are only 3 ingredients listed. Whole Grain Wheat, canola oil and sea salt. I don’t see where it says BHT is listed.

      1. It is listed under the ingredients in small letters. I was grocery shopping on Tuesday and went to purchase them so I could try this recipe and double checked and spotted “contains BHT in packaging to preserve freshness” listed under the ingredients. I guess the organic option doesn’t have it so I’ll have to look for those as they were not available at my local grocery store. Thank you!

    3. I agree – Triscuits are not ideal not only for the possible BHT, but the refined oil as well. I do also buy the Back to Nature brand as another option and Whole Foods has a store brand that is similar as well. I do like that they are 100% whole-grain!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating