No Sugar Green Tomato Relish (Can or Freeze)

7 Reviews / 5 Average
If you're big into canning, this Green Tomato Relish is a must try. I've broken down the steps and tips to make the process easier for beginners. This recipe is from Ashley Eller and Farm Girl Fare, and it's one of my favorites using green tomatoes!
↓ Jump to Recipe
Green Tomato Relish from 100 Days of #RealFood

I’ve been waiting all year to have fresh red tomatoes in my backyard, but this green tomato relish recipe is SO incredibly delicious that I didn’t even think twice about plucking some off the vines before they could even ripen.

I occasionally get obsessed with certain recipes, and my friends – this is one of them! I don’t think it’s a secret that I am also slightly obsessed with the crock-pot refried bean recipe and let me tell you those beans are suddenly reinvented when topped with this relish (in addition to the standard melted cheese and sour cream of course). Not that I haven’t been caught just eating this relish by the spoonful. :) Can you tell I am smitten?

Anyway due to all the chopping and simmering this recipe will require several hours of your time from start to finish, which isn’t a common theme with my recipes so I wanted to be sure to point that out. If you aren’t into the “canning” thing you can easily shave off some time by simply freezing the end results. Either way you won’t regret it…yum!

Also, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention that I was introduced to this recipe at my canning class with Ashley Eller earlier this year. Thank you Ashley!

Canning Basics

If you are new to canning be sure to check out my honey strawberry jam tutorial for some detailed instructions, but in short you will need:

  • Canning pot with or without a rack (a dish towel can also be used to separate jars from bottom)
  • Canning jars with either new or reusable lids (we like the freezable kind with no “shoulders”)
  • Canning utensils including a jar lifter, funnel, bubble remover/headspace tool, and magnetic lid lifter
  • Clean dish towels
  • Sterilized tongs and ladle
  • A digital or analog scale
  • Optional: Thermometer and dissolvable canning labels (I love these labels…no more peeling off old masking tape!)

Also, please note it’s imperative that the rules of canning are always followed to a “T” in order to prevent spoilage or harmful bacteria in your end product!

Posts may contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product through an affiliate link, your cost will be the same but 100 Days of Real Food will automatically receive a small commission. Your support is greatly appreciated and helps us spread our message!

77 thoughts on “No Sugar Green Tomato Relish (Can or Freeze)”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating

  1. Could you replace the Jalapeños? I know that not everyone in the house would appreciate their addition. Just add more bell peppers?

  2. I will give it a go and let you know! I need to reduce the quantity of the ingredients though, as I don’t have a lot of rhubarb. Thank you :D

    1. Wow! I just made this relish this morning. It is amazing:) I will definitely make this every fall when the frost hits and I have an abundance of green tomatoes still on the vine. Thank you!

  3. This sounds delicious…I’m looking for a ‘no sugar’ recipe for rhubarb relish. Do you think this recipe will work (replace tomatoes with rhubarb)? Thanks!

    1. 100 Days Admin

      Hi Dora, we have not tried that with this recipe. If you think you’d enjoy those flavors with rhubarb as a substitute, let us know how it turns out if you give a try! – Nicole

  4. Kathy from Westminster

    I love this recipe, but I had my doubts. How could green tomato relish be good without sugar? It’s so good. I had my three friends over for cards and served it with cream cheese and crackers. They all copied the recipe. The only change I made was to put in 3 jalapeños instead of 8 and I put in fresh cilantro when I served it. Thank you.

  5. I was looking for a recipe for green tomatoes that I didn’t have to can.
    This looks great. How long can you keep it in the freezer? And is the consistency mush when its thawed?

  6. When I processed my jars I never covered the jars in water because I didn’t know I had to, for the hot water bath. They all seem to be sealed well. Are they safe to store?

  7. When I processed my jars in the boiling water bath I did not cover the jars with water since I didn’t know I should. If they are sealed properly are they safe to store? The seals all are seem good, except one.

  8. 5 stars
    What sort of recipes / dishes do you use this on? Is it more of a condiment or do you include it inside of dishes? Thanks for your reply! This looks delicious regardless.

  9. thank you for this recipe, funny it’s on my birthday (the post). I harvested 5 lbs. of cherry tomatoes after a freeze last night (covered up the green tomatoes so they would not freeze). I’m excited to make my first every relish

  10. I always have a lot of green tomatoes that get eaten by squirrels as soon as they turn red. I’m glad to have a good way to use some of these before they disappear.

  11. What if the hot peppers are left out? Are they needed to “make” the flavor of this? It sounds so good – until I get to the hot peppers. I don’t want to leave out an ingredient, spend all that time making this and then finding I should not have left out that ingredient.

  12. Torn out my tomatoes Saturday, so many green ones. So glad I found your recipe, we hit the farmers market for the rest of the ingredients Sunday. Your directions were so easy to follow, it was my first canning experience. My husband was a huge help & loved the fact there was no sugar! He was eating it by the bowl full, topped with a little Greek yogurt! Yum! Took us about 5 hours, we doubled the recipe. We canned 24 half pint jars and filled a variety of jars I had around for the fridge. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

  13. 5 stars
    I just made this this morning and wanted to send my thanks for sharing such a great recipe. This was a home run! Delicious, well balanced, tangy, spicy, slightly sweet from the apples, but the flavors of the veggies shine through. We will be keeping this recipe around. Many thanks!

  14. I have a question on your relish.
    While it is simmering for the 1.5 hours, should it be covered?

    it looks great and i am looking forward to trying it.

    Thank you

  15. Came upon this via Google search for Green Tomato Relish, and was thrilled to find a no-sugar recipe. Also very pleased with your excellent instructions. We made it last night (so much for a long night’s sleep, but we are still smiling!). Forgot to add cumin at the end, and it is still delicious. Might try adding some cumin after the fact, but doesn’t necessarily need it. Thank you very much!

  16. I like the sound of your no sugar green tomato relish & I really appreciate the information about the Tattler Reusable jar lids!!! I cure & can olives and really dislike buying new lids every year. What’s even better, there’s a retailer about 8 miles from our country place!!! Looking forward to trying your recipe and the Tattler lids :-)

  17. 5 stars
    Hoping it will be okay to have chopped all the veggies and measured out the cider vinegar for a triple batch to do in the morning. After prepping it got too late and I have time in the morning. This recipe is amazing and we can’t wait to try it.

  18. Well it is 8:00 pm and I just finished making my first batch of green tomato relish and I must say this is so yummy. Here it is the first of Nov. and I still have lot’s of tomatoe’s mostly green and I was wondering what I could do with all those tomatoe’s,this was the perfect answer. I know I will be making another batch for Xmas gifts if I can dare part with it.
    I love your blog.I do not have children but I love looking at your school lunches,makes me think a litter differently about packing my own lunch.
    Thanks so much so the great ideas and the time you spend on researching products.

  19. This looks great! Can I use regular (white) vinegar or red wine vinegar instead of apple cider, if I’m not canning it? I don’t have any apple cider, and I have everything else so I don’t really want to go shopping…

    I live in Seattle and therefore have too many tomatoes that didn’t have time to turn red. So thank you for the inspiration!

  20. 5 stars
    I have made this many many times and this year I entered it in the Alabama National Fair and won SECOND PLACE!

    The only changes I made are I chopped the veggies very roughly and then use my immersion blender on it after it’s done cooking. I don’t like really chunky stuff. :)

    This is a WONDERFUL recipe. Thank you so much for it! I share it all the time.

  21. I used your recipe, as it sounded the best of all I researched. I processed my veggies to a fine chop, as opposed to blending them after cooking, as I was looking for a looser relish. Thanks for posting.

    I would also recommend the Tattler brand lids. A tad more expensive up front, but saves money and a lot of metal in the long run.

    1. When all was said and done, I tripled the recipe, as I had a fairly good amount of tomatoes. I ended up with 23 pints plus one quart! I also used habaneros and jalapenos; whatever was left in the garden. As this has such a salsa feel, I would probably up the spice level on future batches.

    2. 5 stars
      If you are going to give it as gifts I would use the regular Kerr or Ball lids because you mite not get your reusable ones back.

  22. Hi! This looks delicious! I am wondering about the immersion blender. Is it really necessary? I do not have one and do not really have a good blender to use (though I do have a processor, I imagine it would make a mess to transfer it back and forth). What do you think? Would it still be good if left chunky? Thanks for the recipe, looking forward to trying it!

  23. So I just finished canning a batch of this…yum! Besides topping tortilla chips and refried beans, what other suggestions do you have for using this?

  24. My husband and I have very different tastes when it comes to salsa but we both loved it. Just got done making a batch (eating it warm on tortilla chips right now). YUM! I was a little worried about the vinegar smell during the cooking process, but after adding the last few ingredients, it all came together. Can’t wait to try it with your refried beans, which were also delicious!

  25. I am thinking of trying this now at the end of our tomato season but am wondering where you sourced your raw vinegar. Unfortunately in the small town where I live, such things are hard to come by. Do you only find raw vinegar at specialty type stores?

  26. It tastes sort of like regular pickle relish but better.I mix mine with ketchup and use it on my cheesebuger by the spoonfull per each bite.My recipe is a little different than this one.

  27. Are the reusable lids and canning jars safe for freezer storage or is there a brand you would recommend? I am trying to reduce my carbon footprint, and find a better storage solution than bags in the freezer and fridge. This is a great site, and I have been recommending it to everyone. Thanks!

  28. So is there a trick to picking a green tomato? Just pick it before it turns red? I want to try this recipe before we move and have to leave my beautiful tomato-filled plants behind! Its perfect!

  29. Thanks!!! Made mine last night and got 12 jars! It is fantastic! I still have quite a bit of green tomatoes and think I will make another batch!

  30. Melissa Nowack

    OHHH MY! I was sooo excited to stumble upon your blog on pinterest! I have been gradually trying to eliminate sugar and all processed foods especially over the past year. It sure is a task…and while I do have a homeopathic DR and master herbalist living right next door, who is an immense support for me, I have been looking for recipes…(he has no small children and doesnt understand my need to replace the recipes for chocolate chip cookies, breads and mac and cheese, with acceptable options. So, this site is going to be a lifesaver for me! I am so excited!!!) Anyway, I was immediatlely brought to this link…Green Tomato Relish- I just made this recipe this past fall for the first time and our family just LOVES it. My recipe had sugar in it though- I love the idea of adding apple to the recipe to substitute for the sugar addition. LOVE it! Im so excited. Thanks for doing this blog! I can’t tell you enough!

  31. I’ve been canning for years and NEVER heard of those reusable lids, definitely checking those out! I LOVE green tomatoes and this recipe looks great, especially with the apples…yum, can’t wait to try a batch :)

  32. I’m normally not a fan of green tomatoes, but this looks so delish that I can’t wait to try it! I love that you give directions for canning, since I’m really getting into that this year.

  33. So, I am curious. I have never cooked with green tomatoes but am totally open to it. Also, the list of ingredients varies greatly in tastes from onion to apple to vinegar to jalapeño, etc. I am having a hard time imagining what this relish tastes like. Is it spicy, tangy or somewhat sweet? Can you try to describe the taste please? Thanks!

    1. 100 Days of Real Food

      Oh my gosh it is soooo yummy! I think it’s most similar to the flavor of a really good salsa…my husband says it’s “tangy” and I think it’s a little sweet, but it does have a little kick from the jalapenos and a Mexican flavor from the cumin.

  34. Thank you for pointing out the Reusable Canning Lid product. Been canning for years and never heard of it. I never liked the metal lids. I’m going to find these and buy them if I can!

  35. To answer Ashley’s question directly, the answer is yes, trace amounts of formaldehyde are present in the polyoxymethylene copolymer we use, much like hydrogen is molecularly bonded in water, and carbon dioxide is molecularly bonded in air. However, the conditions required to cause a molecular breakdown releasing formaldehyde are only present at temperatures above 460 degrees fahrenheit. The melt point of the plastic is 329 degrees fehrenheit, which itself is significantly higher than safe canning practices allow at 250 degrees for pressure canning. Practically speaking, the release of formaldehyde is only a concern when extreme heat (460 F) or significant flame is present, as in the case of a structure fire.

    You can find additional information related to our product by visiting our company website at .

  36. This sounds delicious, I can’t wait to try it! I have a question about the Tattler reusable lids- I’ve come across them before when searching for a BPA-free canning lids, but apparently Polyoxymethylene copolymer is made from formaldehyde, so that made me nervous. (Not that BPA doesn’t make me nervous…! ) Tree Hugger wrote about them here: Do you have any info about the Tattler lids to ease my mind about them (am I misunderstanding the formaldehyde thing)? Thanks!

    1. 100 Days of Real Food

      Ashley – I want to make sure you saw the answer to your question…Brad from Tattler answered it, but it wasn’t left as a reply (instead as a new comment).

      1. I did see it, thank you so much. I’m glad they became your sponsor because I’d been wondering about their lids for literally a year but never went through the extra step of contacting them with my concerns. I feel good about his response so I’ll be using their lids this canning season. Thanks again!

  37. The one part that makes me nervous is all the apple cider vinegar. I can’t STAND the smell of that stuff, and even though I know it’s so healthy, I hardly use it. Do you still notice it once this recipe is finished?

    1. 100 Days of Real Food

      I personally don’t notice the vinegar flavor, but if that concerns you and you are NOT going to can the recipe you could reduce the amount of vinegar and store the relish in the freezer.