I've been tasked with bringing a dish to a pot luck gathering on Saturday, and I'm guessing I am not alone this time of year. December could almost be dubbed the "Month of Pot Luck Parties" so I'm here to share some ideas of what you can bring to all your holiday gatherings in the coming weeks.
Oh and I was asked to bring a dessert, but I can't decide between the Whole-Wheat Madeleines and No-Bake Peanut Butter Dessert Bars ... both are just too good! Maybe you guys can help be the tie breaker, what do you think? :)
Want to Save this Recipe?
Enter your email below & we'll send it straight to your inbox. Plus you'll get great new recipes from us every week!
Appetizers and Sides
1. Chopped Salad
This one is at the top of the list for a reason. I've made it for multiple group gatherings, and it's always a HUGE hit! To the point where people will ask you for the recipe ... so, go for it!
2. Crab and Corn Cakes
This is one of those fabulous dishes that tastes great warm or at room temp ... the perfect kind of appetizer when you know it will be sitting out for a couple hours!
3. Melt-in-Your-Mouth Cream Biscuits
These are not only my favorite biscuits, but they are the easiest to make. You could even have your elementary-aged children whip these up for you if you don't have the time.
4. Creamy Kale Caesar Salad
Kale is all the rage for health reasons these days, and this recipe is the perfect combo to prove it actually tastes good, too! Add something light to the buffet table with this one.
5. Deviled Eggs
If you're looking for a budget-friendly appetizer, this is it! It's been my go-to for years when it comes to pot luck gatherings because I always have eggs on hand, and they are almost always a crowd-pleaser (especially for those with special dietary needs).
Desserts
6. Whole-Wheat Madeleines
I've honestly been looking for an excuse to make these again ... so simple, yet fancy and tasty. The lemon flavor gives these "cookies" a lighter flavor than other more-typical desserts this time of year.
7. Chocolate Chip Blondies
A twist to your standard chocolate chip cookie ... I never met a chocolate chip cookie I didn't like, and these are no exception!
8. 5-Minute Brownies
I'm not sure homemade brownies need an explanation? You'll definitely come home with an empty dish if you decide to bring these!
9. Blueberry Lemon Bundt Cake
Nothing speaks "special" like a bundt cake, so this one will stand out on the dessert table or be a perfect addition to a sit-down holiday dinner gathering with friends.
10. No-Bake Peanut Butter Dessert Bars
I promise you can never go wrong with these. They're dangerous to have around my house for too long, so I only make them when I know I'll get to share with lots of willing people!
So what's your vote for me to take Saturday night? Whole-Wheat Madeleines or No-Bake Peanut Butter Dessert Bars?
Eric says
My main reason to look for other recipes is to find meal ideas that are aligned with a diabetic need to reduce sugar and simple starches in the diet. Only 2 of your 9 recipes meet this criteria. I went from being under control (blood sugar less than 120) to being about 150 each morning over the Holidays. When I eat out or at gatherings I blow it even when limiting calories and indulging. Now that I am back home in two days my blood sugar is back to <120. I lost 10 lbs and that really helped but the slightest infraction pushes the numbers up. I'm happy that I haven't seen anything over 200 or even close in a very long time but want to keep these numbers down. I need to lose another 20 lbs and finally see a path to get there but am too easily tempted to stray during the Holidays especially. The good news is that I didn't gain any weight.
Lisa says
Love your recipes, but it's kind of annoying when I click a link from your email and get a pop to to join your mailing list every time. Obviously I'm on your list.
Julie says
Agree
Shelby says
Wish I was at your potluck so I could try the peanut butter bars!! Guess I'll have to make some soon!
Robin Goodman says
Peanut butter bars. Good excuse to make something that rich and not have to keep the whole pan in the house.
Madeline's for Santa.
Tess D says
I'm no use as a tie-breaker, cuz they both look great to me, too!
But I have a question about the chopped salad. It looks delish, but I notice it serves 3-4 people. Have you ever made a larger "batch" and changed the presentation? I guess I could use a larger platter, but also wondering how it would do as a layered salad, maybe in a trifle dish.
Amy Taylor (comment moderator) says
Hi. I think it would work fine as a layered salad, too. :)
Jan says
What a silly question--Peanut Butter Bars, of course. ;)
knitogether says
Hands down the peanut butter bars!
Holly Rosene says
I would bring the whole wheat Madelienes for dessert. They will be different and extra special.
Katyana says
I've made the devilled eggs already for a Halloween Pot Luck and they disappeared in a flash!
Susan Brandenburg says
Peanut butter bars! I can't wait to try them!!
yvonne says
I would definitely go with the Peanut Butter bars! But then, I have a serious weakness for anything with peanut butter, so I'm a little biased. ;)
Either way, have a wonderful time at your pot-luck!
Cathy says
Peanut butter bars! Who can resist chocolate and peanut butter together??
Marie says
Peanut Butter Bars, Hands down!
Brooke says
I vote PB bars. Thanks for the list!
Donna says
Although I am a Peanut butter Lover... I think the Madeleines are more Elegant to bring to a Holliday Gathering. Yum to Both!! xoxo
Louie says
Yep, the peanut butter bars are one of our favourites!
Jessica says
PB Bars! Can't wait to try them myself!
Emma says
I love the madeleines! A potluck is the perfect reason to make them! and they always smell so delicious!! When I first saw your recipe for them (when you went to cooking school with your daughter), I actually bought a madeleine baking pan off of Amazon and I've made them a few times now - always a big hit!!
Janel says
The peanut butter bars. They're amazing.
Catherine says
The chocolate chip blondies look delectable to me ... will have to bring them to my next social gathering!
Beth says
My vote is No-Bake Peanut Butter Dessert Bars ALL THE WAY! And I'm book-marking the recipe so I can make 'em too. :)
LeeAnn says
I vote for the Madeleines... tho' the bars look good too.